Pitfalls in HTTP Traffic Measurements and Analysis

Being responsible for more than half of the total traffic volume in the Internet, HTTP is a popular subject for traffic analysis. From our experiences with HTTP traffic analysis we identified a number of pitfalls which can render a carefully executed study flawed. Often these pitfalls can be avoided easily. Based on passive traffic measurements of 20.000 European residential broadband customers, we quantify the potential error of three issues: Non-consideration of persistent or pipelined HTTP requests, mismatches between the Content-Type header field and the actual content, and mismatches between the Content-Length header and the actual transmitted volume. We find that 60 % (30 %) of all HTTP requests (bytes) are persistent (i. e., not the first in a TCP connection) and 4 % are pipelined. Moreover, we observe a Content-Type mismatch for 35 % of the total HTTP volume. In terms of Content-Length accuracy our data shows a factor of at least 3.2 more bytes reported in the HTTP header than actually transferred.